Knowledge resource – Conceptualising inclusive in engineering-driven inclusive innovation: case of Indian AI-based MedTech

Toolkit: Inclusive Engineering Toolkit

Author(s):  Dr Pallavi Joshi (The Open University, UK), Prof Dinar Kale (The Open University, UK), Dr Aravinda Meera Guntupalli (University of Aberdeen), Prof David Wield (The Open University, UK)

Resource type:  Knowledge article: Inclusion in engineering contexts (e.g. how inclusion shapes engineering practice, design decisions, teamwork, and outcomes in real engineering contexts)

Topic: Conceptualising inclusivity using case studies of AI-based MedTech for cancer detection in India.

Title: Conceptualising inclusivity in engineering-driven inclusive innovation: case of Indian AI-based MedTech

Relevant disciplines: Bioengineering, medical & biomedical engineering; IT, systems sciences & computer software engineering

Keywords:  Inclusive Engineering; Equity, Diversity and Inclusion; Technology; Innovation; Access and participation; Stakeholders; Systems thinking; Collaboration; Enterprise and innovation; Knowledge or Guidance

Licensing: This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Downloads: A PDF of this resource will be available soon.

QAA Inclusive Higher Education Framework mapping:  Toolkit resources are designed to be applicable across engineering disciplines, but educators may find it useful to understand their alignment with the QAA Inclusive Higher Education Framework. The framework sets out five areas of activity that support inclusive practice across higher education, covering curriculum design, teaching and learning, assessment, learner support, and institutional approaches to inclusion.

This resource aligns most closely with the following QAA Inclusive Higher Education Framework area of activity: Curriculum Design and Delivery; Community and Belonging

Within the Inclusive Engineering Toolkit, these areas provide a reference point for understanding how resources support inclusive engineering education and practice, rather than defining a rigid taxonomy or classification system.

AHEP mapping: This resource addresses several of the themes from the UK’s Accreditation of Higher Education Programmes fourth edition (AHEP4):  Equality, Diversity and Inclusion. In addition, Design and Integrated or systems approach.

Education Level: Intermediate.

 

Learning and teaching materials:

The contribution requires reading and analysis of the article:

 

Premise

Early detection of cancers is a major challenge in India due to the limited availability and access to early detection modalities in low-resource healthcare settings. Recent artificial intelligence (AI)-driven point-of-care (PoC) medical technology (MedTech) innovations for early detection of cancer have shown some signs of bridging this gap. This contribution presents evidence from three detailed case studies of PoC AI-based MedTech inclusive innovations developed by Indian start-ups for the early detection of breast, cervical and oral cancers. There are two main results. First, the work shows the importance of integrating health policy and industrial policy. Surprisingly, such integration is rare. Health policy has assumed that globally available technologies can readily be accessed given appropriate funding mechanisms. The early period of the COVID-19 pandemic disproved this assumption. Second, it builds a conception of inclusiveness as applied to innovation processes, and the implications for early detection of cancer in India.

 

Main body

The article has a range of materials that are useful for building concepts and practices of inclusive engineering.

The abstract and introduction illustrate that the focus on context-specific inclusive innovations for Indian cancer care is relevant to many geographies in low- and middle-income countries and in situations of low-resource healthcare. The article focuses on two key research questions:

1. What are the actors and networks, knowledge and technologies, and institutions shaping different early detection modalities, particularly contextualising AI-based PoC MedTech’s, in the Indian context?

2. How can inclusiveness be conceptualised in emerging AI-based PoC innovations, and what implications does it hold for the early detection of cancer in India?

 

Section 2

Section 2 explains the qualitative research methods used in the article. The article uses 16 online semi-structured interviews undertaken with policymakers, representatives of key industry associations, incubators, and senior management of diagnostic firms offering various screening modalities of cancer, venture capitalists, clinical research scientists, and biomedical engineers in 2021 and 2022. These participants were chosen for their direct involvement in the innovation ecosystem or their role in shaping the trajectory of AI-based MedTech in India within the landscape of early detection of cancer in India. The secondary data, collated between 2019 and 2023, were used to triangulate findings and enhance the validity of the results. These included reports and publications of the Indian government, the Clinical Trial Registry of India, key industry reports, multilateral organisations, relevant podcasts, and publicly available interviews of innovators.

 

Section 3

Section 3 of the article examines the actors and networks, knowledge and technologies, and institutions shaping these early detection modalities in India. It provides a detailed analysis of the context surrounding potential inclusive innovations. It allows analysis of different levels of technology in differing geographies.

 

Section 4

Section 4 contains the detailed case studies.

As a teaching and learning activity, here are two questions that can be answered from studying the three case studies:

1. What constitutes the engineering in each case?

2. What makes the engineering innovation inclusive in each case?

 

Section 5

Conceptualisation of inclusiveness is the focus of section 5. Section 5 is, perhaps, the most relevant section for readers more narrowly interested in inclusiveness. Broadly, inclusive innovation is defined as the inclusion of marginalised groups in certain aspects of innovation. The article expands this definition to highlight the role of key institutions, actors and factors shaping inclusiveness in the innovation processes and innovation outcomes.

The cases illustrate a range of elements of inclusiveness.

There is inclusivity in the Innovation process. The AI-based MedTech products increased the potential for cancer diagnosis in difficult-to-reach social groups and geographies. The innovators framed unmet needs as their focus and spent major effort building understanding of the needs of users. The products enabled screening and early diagnosis at the point of care. Many inclusive innovations are framed as low-tech and low-cost. Interestingly, these showed the importance of high technology to address low-resource healthcare challenges.

There is inclusivity in the outcomes of innovation. The products could be accessed in rural areas and by more marginal social groups. Policy initiatives to support women innovators involved in shaping MedTech that are meant for women users emerged as a crucial finding. And end users were able to contribute to improvements in design and use due to the nature of the machine learning algorithms, necessitating data privacy and regulatory norms.  Table 2 has a detailed summary of elements of inclusivity. Can you think of further elements of inclusivity?

Table 3 summarises the variety of business models used to diffuse the innovations based on different strategies that include specific settings for screening.  Might other business models be useful? 

 

Conclusions

The main conclusions are:

1. There is great potential for high-tech MedTech to reshape health care access in low-resource healthcare settings

2. There is a new trajectory of inclusive innovation, not driven by large companies, but by engineers and researchers with personal motivation to improve cancer and health care

3. There is a role for private actors in low- and middle-income countries as producers of innovations. The innovations were driven by engineers and scientists leveraging advanced computing technologies, yet designed to meet specific needs in low-resource healthcare settings

4. The innovations allow for more equitable access, addressing both vertical inequalities (income and wealth related) and horizontal inequalities (like gender, geographical and cultural access barriers – all particularly important in these cases. Inclusivity involves a broader approach, rethinking innovation systems that integrate local needs with industrial production, the creation of new markets, and strong governance that bring together actors, institutions, and so on in creative ways.

Details can be found in Section 6 of the article.

 

References

  • Joshi, P., Kale, D., Guntupalli, A.M. and Wield, D. (2026) ‘Conceptualising inclusive in inclusive innovations: evidence from the AI-based MedTech for cancer detection in India’, Science and Public Policy, 53(1), pp. 131–144. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1093/scipol/scaf081.

 

Any views, thoughts, and opinions expressed herein are solely that of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, policies, or position of the Engineering Professors’ Council or the Toolkit sponsors and supporters.  

All contributions published through the Inclusive Engineering Toolkit have been subject to a structured peer review process to support quality, relevance, and consistency.    

The Inclusive Engineering Toolkit recognises that inclusive language and terminology may vary across contexts and communities, and that contributors may use different approaches depending on context and preference, including identity-first and person-first language. Users are encouraged to contact us at admin@epc.ac.uk with any questions, concerns, or feedback regarding language used within toolkit resources.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most voted
Let us know what you think of our website